Premier League transfers: Ranking the impact made by all 155 summer signings

The article announces the return of a popular feature ranking the impact of all 155 Premier League summer signings from the 2025 season, coinciding with the January transfer window's opening. It clarifies that this ranking is not a measure of overall player quality but a weighted power list based solely on the immediate impact each signing has had on their new club over approximately four months, excluding future potential.

The piece uses examples to illustrate its criteria, noting that a player's statistical output, like a high goals-per-minute ratio, can outweigh perceived technical quality. It also mentions that player performances have fluctuated since the last ranking, with some declining, some improving, and others hampered by injury.

The article then provides a specific case study, highlighting Harvey Elliott's loan move to Aston Villa as a particularly poor signing. It notes his dramatic drop in the rankings and criticizes the transfer, suggesting a lack of managerial consultation has led to a situation where the player is unused and may be returned to Liverpool in January.