The New York Red Bulls and FC Dallas drew 2-2 in the U.S. Open Cup on May 22, 2025, with the tie ultimately decided by a penalty shootout. This back-and-forth encounter at Red Bull Arena was a classic cup contest. FC Dallas took the lead twice, showing great composure on the counter-attack. Each time, the Red Bulls found an answer, with their second equalizer coming in the dying minutes of normal time to force extra time. After a tense but goalless extra period, the match went to penalties. In the shootout, FC Dallas displayed superior accuracy to advance to the next round. The result was a cruel exit for the Red Bulls after their dramatic late rally, while it provided a memorable away triumph for Dallas. The Dallas coach would highlight his team's mental strength, while the Red Bulls' manager would focus on the positives of his team's fighting spirit.